2014 — Baby A (Suing through the Mother E.A.) v Attorney General & 6 Others, Kenya

2014 — Baby A (Suing through the Mother E.A.) v Attorney General & 6 Others, Kenya

Baby ‘A’ (Suing through the Mother E.A.) & another v. Attorney General & 6 others [2014] is a landmark Kenyatta National Hospital and Kenyan High Court decision concerning intersex rights. The court ruled that an intersex child must be issued a birth certificate and ordered the government to collect intersex data and regulate medical surgery, while noting that creating a new gender marker requires legislative action.

Born in May 2009 with both male and female genitalia, Baby A received medical documentation with a question mark (?) under “sex” and was denied a birth certificate. Baby A’s mother (E.A.), the petitioner in this case, faced several challenges trying to register the birth of her baby which required a determinate sex category as either male or female — categories that her baby did not fit. As a result, her baby was not issued a birth certificate. In these cases, many intersex children are forced to undergo corrective surgery, which undermines their right to self-autonomy and brings about many other challenges later on in their adult life.

E.A. brought the case to the High Court, represented by John Chigiti, claiming that not having a birth certificate denies the baby legal recognition (suing for legal discrimination) and the ability to enjoy other rights like the right to education and Medicare care. Filed in 2013, it argued that the lack of legal identity and registration violated fundamental rights to dignity and freedom from degrading treatment. Read more about the petitioner’s case and the ruling.

Ruling:

  • Right to identity: The court ordered the Registrar of Births and Deaths to register Baby A and issue a birth certificate within 90 days.
    Medical oversight: The government was directed to formulate proper administrative guidelines for conducting medical examinations and managing corrective surgeries on intersex infants.
    Data collection: Ordered official state data collection and enumeration efforts for intersex individuals.
    Limits of the judiciary: The court declined to judicially introduce a third “intersex” gender category, declaring it a policy matter for Parliament to legislate.

Watch our interview with intersex activist, Julius Kaggwa, about the Baby A case

Read more about intersex laws in Kenya: